S355NL vs S460NL Steel Plate: EN 10025-3 Comparison

Dec 25, 2025 Leave a message

What EN 10025-3 Covers

EN 10025-3 is the part of the European structural steel series that deals with normalized, weldable fine-grain steels. The designation carries three signals: the number is the minimum yield strength in MPa, N indicates the normalized delivery condition, and L indicates that impact testing is carried out at -50 °C. S355NL and S460NL therefore differ in strength level while sharing the same delivery condition, the same fine-grain treatment and the same low-temperature toughness requirement.

Fine-grain treatment is achieved with aluminum and microalloying additions, and the normalized condition gives a uniform ferritic-pearlitic structure with a guaranteed toughness level. That combination is why these grades are preferred for structures that combine heavy static loading with a risk of brittle fracture: bridges in cold regions, wind turbine towers, offshore platforms, cranes, storage tanks and large welded frames.

Chemical Composition

Element, max % S355NL, ladle S355NL, product S460NL, ladle S460NL, product
C 0.18 0.20 0.20 0.22
Si 0.50 0.55 0.60 0.65
Mn 0.90-1.65 0.85-1.75 1.00-1.70 0.95-1.80
P 0.025 0.035 0.025 0.030
S 0.015 0.025 0.020 0.025
N 0.015 0.017 0.025 0.027
Al, min 0.020 0.015 0.020 0.015
Nb 0.05 0.06 0.05 0.06
V 0.12 0.15 0.20 0.22
Ti 0.05 0.06 0.05 0.06
Cr 0.30 0.35 0.30 0.35
Ni 0.30 0.35 0.80 0.85
Mo 0.10 0.13 0.10 0.12
Cu 0.55 0.60 0.55 0.60

S460NL allows more vanadium and nickel than S355NL. Vanadium contributes precipitation strengthening, and nickel improves low-temperature toughness, which is what permits the higher strength level to be combined with the same -50 °C impact requirement. Both grades are fully killed with a minimum aluminum content to bind nitrogen, and the ladle and product analysis limits are published separately so that a small change introduced during casting and rolling is still acceptable without invalidating the heat.

Mechanical Properties and Thickness Effect

Thickness, mm S355NL ReH min, MPa S355NL tensile, MPa S460NL ReH min, MPa S460NL tensile, MPa
≤16 355 470-630 460 540-720
>16-40 345 470-630 440 540-720
>40-63 335 470-630 430 540-720
>63-80 325 470-630 410 540-720
>80-100 305 470-630 390 540-720
>100-150 285 450-610 380 510-690
>150-200 265 450-610 370 510-690
>200-250 245 450-610 360 510-690

Both grades lose strength as thickness increases, and both retain a 27 J minimum Charpy V-notch energy at -50 °C in the longitudinal direction across the thickness range. Elongation minima are 22% for S355NL up to about 63 mm, falling to 21% in heavier plate, and 17% for S460NL. The practical consequence is that the 105 MPa strength advantage of S460NL is maintained across the whole thickness range, so the weight saving does not disappear in heavy sections.

Choosing Between Them

S355NL is the default for heavily loaded but conventionally proportioned work: bridge girders, crane runways, stadium and industrial structures, tank supports, tower bases and general heavy fabrication, including projects that must combine -50 °C toughness with straightforward welding. It is widely available in thicknesses up to 250 mm and its welding procedures are well established.

S460NL becomes attractive when the design stress is high enough that member size is controlled by strength rather than by deflection, buckling or fatigue. Typical applications are long-span bridge chords, wind turbine tower flanges and shells, offshore lifting appliances, heavy crane booms, hydroelectric gates and large machine frames. Replacing S355NL with S460NL can reduce steel weight by 20-25% at the same load, which lowers transport and erection cost and reduces weld volume.

The saving must be checked against three constraints. Stiffness is governed by elastic modulus, which is the same for both grades, so deflection-critical members do not shrink. Stability of slender compression members depends on geometry, so thinner plate may need more stiffening. Fatigue strength is governed by detail geometry and weld quality rather than by strength class, so higher-strength steel does not automatically raise fatigue life. Where all three are satisfied, the heavier grade usually wins on total installed cost.

Fabrication, Welding and Quality Control

S460NL demands a little more discipline in the workshop. Preheating, heat input and interpass temperature are specified in a qualified welding procedure, and the higher vanadium content in the parent metal must be matched by consumables that avoid excessive strength or hardness in the weld metal and heat-affected zone. S355NL is more forgiving and can be welded with routine low-hydrogen practice for moderate thicknesses.

Both grades are supplied normalized, with normalizing rolling permitted where the producer qualifies the route, and both may be ordered with ultrasonic examination to EN 10160, thickness-direction testing to EN 10164, and restricted carbon equivalent for improved weldability. Cutting is by plasma, laser, waterjet or flame, and cold forming should respect minimum bend radii so that surface strain does not reduce toughness.

Incoming inspection verifies the EN 10204 certificate, heat number marking, dimensions, flatness, surface quality and, where ordered, impact and ultrasonic results. For structures in cold climates, the certificate review should confirm that the impact test temperature and specimen orientation match the project specification, because a mismatch between -20 °C and -50 °C qualities is the most common error found in material review.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is the difference between S355NL and S460NL?

A: The minimum yield strength, 355 MPa against 460 MPa. Both are normalized fine-grain steels to EN 10025-3, both are tested at -50 °C and both are delivered in the normalized condition.

Q: What does the L in S355NL indicate?

A: L denotes the low-temperature impact quality, with Charpy V-notch testing at -50 °C and a minimum absorbed energy of 27 J.

Q: Can S460NL replace S355NL directly?

A: Only after checking deflection, buckling and fatigue, which are not improved by the higher yield strength, and after confirming that the fabrication procedure suits the higher-strength steel.

Q: What thicknesses are available?

A: EN 10025-3 covers normalized plate up to 250 mm, with the S355NL range commonly stocked from 8 mm and S460NL normally produced from 8 mm to 150 mm.

Q: Do both grades need ultrasonic examination?

A: It is not a base requirement. It is ordered as a supplementary test, usually to EN 10160, for structures where internal soundness is critical.

Q: Which grade is used for wind tower components?

A: Both are used, with S355NL typical for shells and S460NL selected for flanges and highly loaded sections where lower wall thickness reduces weight.