S355NL vs S355N Steel Plate: Impact Toughness at -50 and -20 Degrees

Dec 24, 2025 Leave a message

S355NL and S355N at a Glance

S355NL and S355N are two grades from the same family: EN 10025-3, the standard for normalized or normalized rolled weldable fine-grain structural steels. They share the same minimum yield strength of 355 MPa, the same tensile range, the same chemistry limits and the same carbon equivalent. The single property that separates them is the temperature at which low-temperature impact toughness is guaranteed: -20 °C for S355N and -50 °C for S355NL.

The choice between them is driven by the service temperature of the finished structure.

Reading the Grade Designation

S - structural steel.

355 - minimum yield strength in MPa at thickness up to 16 mm.

N - normalized or normalized rolled delivery condition, with Charpy impact testing at -20 °C.

NL - normalized or normalized rolled delivery condition, with Charpy impact testing at -50 °C.

Both grades are fine-grain steels with a controlled ferritic grain size, which is what allows the steel to absorb energy at low temperature without brittle fracture.

Chemical Composition Compared

Element (ladle, max %) S355NL (EN 10025-3) S355N (EN 10025-3)
Carbon 0.18 0.20
Silicon 0.50 0.50
Manganese 0.90 to 1.65 0.90 to 1.65
Phosphorus 0.025 0.030
Sulphur 0.015 0.025
Nitrogen 0.015 0.015
Aluminium (min, total) 0.020 0.020
Niobium 0.05 0.05
Vanadium 0.12 0.12
Titanium 0.05 0.05
Chromium 0.30 0.30
Nickel 0.30 0.50
Molybdenum 0.10 0.10
Copper 0.55 0.55
Carbon equivalent (max) 0.43 0.43

S355NL is held to lower maximum carbon, phosphorus and sulphur, which is one reason it can be certified for -50 °C impact testing.

Mechanical Properties Compared

Property S355NL (EN 10025-3) S355N (EN 10025-3)
Minimum yield strength, thickness ≤ 16 mm 355 MPa 355 MPa
Minimum yield strength, thickness above 16 to 40 mm 345 MPa 345 MPa
Minimum yield strength, thickness above 40 mm 335 MPa 335 MPa
Tensile strength 470 to 630 MPa 470 to 630 MPa
Minimum elongation, thickness ≤ 40 mm 22% 22%
Impact energy, longitudinal 27 J minimum at -50 °C 27 J minimum at -20 °C

The strength columns are identical by design, so both grades can be used with the same allowable stresses. Only the toughness column changes.

Welding, Heat Treatment and Applications

Welding. Both grades are welded with the usual arc processes following EN 1011-2. For gas metal arc welding, a solid wire such as ER70S-6 is appropriate; for submerged arc welding, an EM12K flux combined with an EH14 wire gives matching strength and toughness. Preheat of 100 to 150 °C is applied for thicknesses above 20 mm.

Welding differences. The difference between welding S355N and S355NL is small, because both have a carbon equivalent of 0.43 maximum. S355NL benefits from lower sulphur and phosphorus, which slightly improves heat-affected zone toughness.

Applications. S355NL is chosen for offshore platforms in cold marine environments, wind towers in sub-zero climates, and bridges and cranes in arctic regions, where the -50 °C impact guarantee is part of the design case. S355N is used for building frameworks, bridges and machinery in temperate climates, where -20 °C toughness is sufficient at a lower cost.

Equivalent designations. S355NL is commonly compared with ASTM A633 Grade E and S355N with ASTM A572 Grade 60. Legacy designations such as DIN 17102 StE 355 and the older GB/T 1591 Q345 grades do not distinguish the -20 °C from the -50 °C variant, so the EN 10025-3 designation should always be stated in full.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is the difference between S355NL and S355N?
Both are EN 10025-3 normalized fine-grain steels with a 355 MPa minimum yield strength. S355NL guarantees Charpy impact energy at -50 °C, while S355N guarantees it at -20 °C.

Q: Are S355NL and S355N the same strength?
Yes. Yield strength, tensile strength and elongation limits are identical, so the two grades are interchangeable in strength terms.

Q: What does the letter L mean in S355NL?
The L indicates that impact toughness is verified at a lower test temperature, -50 °C instead of -20 °C, which qualifies the steel for cold climate service.

Q: Can S355N be used at -50 °C?
No. S355N is qualified down to -20 °C only. Sub-zero service below that temperature requires the L variant, S355NL.

Q: Which filler metals are used for welding S355NL?
ER70S-6 solid wire for gas metal arc welding and an EM12K flux with EH14 wire for submerged arc welding are typical choices, with preheating above 20 mm thickness.

Q: Where is S355NL commonly used?
Offshore platforms in cold waters, wind towers in sub-zero climates, arctic bridges and cranes, and other structures where brittle fracture resistance at very low temperature is essential.