P275 NL1 vs P275 NL2 Steel Plate: EN 10028-3 Differences Explained

Dec 10, 2025 Leave a message

What EN 10028-3 P275 Steel Plate Is

P275 NL1 and P275 NL2 are both weldable fine grain steel plate grades covered by EN 10028-3, the European specification for flat products made of steel for pressure purposes. Plates in this standard are supplied in the normalized condition and are intended for boilers, pressure vessels, storage tanks, heat exchangers and pressure piping where a guaranteed combination of strength and low temperature toughness is essential.

The grade designation already carries most of the technical information. The letter P marks pressure purposes. The number 275 is the minimum yield strength in MPa for plate 16 mm thick and below. The suffix describes the impact testing regime: the N and NH variants are impact tested at -20 °C or above, NL1 at -40 °C or above and NL2 at -50 °C or above. EN 10028-3 covers three base strength levels, namely P275, P355 and P460, so P275 is the lowest strength and the most formable of the normalized fine grain family.

P275 NL1 vs P275 NL2: The Essential Difference

The two grades sit in the same strength class and share one mechanical property table. The separation lies in the guaranteed impact test temperature and in the tighter impurity limits demanded for NL2.

Item P275 NL1 P275 NL2
Standard EN 10028-3 EN 10028-3
Delivery condition Normalized (+N) Normalized (+N)
Minimum yield strength, t up to 16 mm 275 MPa 275 MPa
Charpy impact test temperature -40 °C or above -50 °C or above
Maximum phosphorus 0.025 % 0.020 %
Maximum sulphur 0.015 % 0.010 %
Typical minimum metal temperature -40 °C -50 °C

A 10 °C lower test temperature looks like a small step, yet it decides which grade is acceptable for a given design. P275 NL2 is selected for cold climate installations, liquefied gas service and any pressure envelope whose minimum design metal temperature falls between -40 °C and -50 °C. Because NL2 also restricts phosphorus and sulphur more severely, it reduces the risk of temper embrittlement and of centreline segregation in heavy plate, which helps the weld heat affected zone retain its toughness after welding.

Chemical Composition of P275 NL1 and P275 NL2

Both grades are low carbon, fine grain steels micro-alloyed through aluminium and a small nitrogen addition. The chemistry below reflects the heat analysis limits applied to the P275 family in EN 10028-3.

Element P275 NL1 P275 NL2
Carbon, C 0.16 % max 0.16 % max
Silicon, Si 0.40 % max 0.40 % max
Manganese, Mn 0.80 - 1.50 % 0.80 - 1.50 %
Phosphorus, P 0.025 % max 0.020 % max
Sulphur, S 0.015 % max 0.010 % max
Total aluminium, Al 0.020 % min 0.020 % min
Nitrogen, N 0.012 % max 0.012 % max

The micro-alloying elements that refine the grain are deliberately kept low: niobium, titanium and vanadium additions each remain at or below 0.05 %, 0.03 % and 0.10 % respectively. Low carbon keeps the carbon equivalent moderate, so P275 plate is readily welded by shielded metal arc, submerged arc and gas shielded processes without preheating in most shop conditions. Where thicker sections or higher restraint apply, a modest preheat is still good practice.

Mechanical Properties by Thickness

Yield strength falls as plate thickness increases, and the same ladder applies to both the NL1 and the NL2 variant.

Nominal thickness Minimum yield strength, ReH
Up to 16 mm 275 MPa
Over 16 mm up to 40 mm 265 MPa
Over 40 mm up to 60 mm 255 MPa
Over 60 mm up to 100 mm 235 MPa
Over 100 mm up to 150 mm 225 MPa
Over 150 mm up to 250 mm 215 MPa

Tensile strength for the common supply range up to 60 mm is 410 to 580 MPa, and the minimum elongation at fracture is 24 %. Because P275 is a normalized fine grain steel, the property table is stable through the thickness and does not rely on accelerated cooling, so plates can be formed cold, hot formed and normalized again after forming without losing the guaranteed values.

Impact Toughness: The Decisive Test

Charpy V-notch testing is performed on normalized test pieces taken transverse to the rolling direction, and the test temperature is the value promised by the suffix of the grade. P275 NL1 must absorb the specified minimum energy at -40 °C, while P275 NL2 must do so at -50 °C. Both grades comfortably exceed the requirement at warmer temperatures, which is why the distinction only matters for genuinely cold service.

Charpy V-notch, transverse to rolling direction, on normalized samples.

P275 NL1 tested at -40 °C; P275 NL2 tested at -50 °C.

Impact energy is verified on each test unit of the delivery, not on a type approval.

Both grades combine the same 275 MPa yield strength with the same tensile band.

How to Choose Between P275 NL1 and P275 NL2

Start from the minimum design metal temperature of the pressure envelope. If it is -40 °C or warmer, P275 NL1 is sufficient and is normally the more economical and more widely stocked option. If it falls between -40 °C and -50 °C, P275 NL2 is the correct grade, because NL1 carries no toughness guarantee below -40 °C. For very thick sections and highly restrained welded joints, the lower phosphorus and sulphur of NL2 also improve the toughness of the heat affected zone, so NL2 can be justified on weldability grounds alone even when the design temperature sits at -40 °C.

Both grades are commonly stocked in the normalized condition, can be supplied with ultrasonic testing to EN 10160, and are frequently ordered with third party inspection for pressure equipment. Plate edges are normally supplied sheared or flame cut, and thickness tolerances follow the normal or special tolerances of EN 10029 according to the order.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Are P275 NL1 and P275 NL2 the same strength steel?
Yes. Both have a minimum yield strength of 275 MPa up to 16 mm and share an identical yield and tensile strength table across all thickness ranges.

Q: What is the real difference between P275 NL1 and P275 NL2?
The impact test temperature, which is -40 °C for NL1 and -50 °C for NL2, together with tighter maximum phosphorus and sulphur limits in the NL2 grade.

Q: Can P275 NL1 be used at -50 °C?
No. NL1 only guarantees Charpy toughness at -40 °C and above, so service at -50 °C requires P275 NL2 or another grade qualified for that temperature.

Q: Is P275 NL2 weldable without preheat?
Its low carbon and low carbon equivalent make it weldable with normal consumables; preheat depends on thickness and restraint and should follow the qualified welding procedure.

Q: Which delivery condition are these plates supplied in?
Both grades are delivered normalized, marked +N, and the fine grain structure is achieved by that normalization rather than by accelerated cooling.

Q: What tests accompany a P275 plate delivery?
Mill certificates normally report heat analysis, tensile properties and Charpy V-notch results at the grade test temperature, and ultrasonic testing can be added when specified.