S235JR vs S355JR Steel: Differences, Data and Equivalent Grades

Jul 25, 2025 Leave a message

S235JR and S355JR are the two basic hot-rolled structural steel plate grades of EN 10025-2, and they are often quoted side by side in structural enquiries. The decisive difference is minimum yield strength, but chemistry limits, impact testing and cross-standard equivalents also change between them. Understanding all four points prevents the kind of substitution that looks acceptable on a mill certificate but fails the design check.

Decoding S235JR and S355JR

In EN 10025-2, S means structural steel and the number is the minimum yield strength in MPa at the smallest thickness range, up to 16 mm. The suffix JR fixes the impact test condition: Charpy V-notch specimens tested at +20 °C must absorb at least 27 J longitudinally. So S235JR guarantees 235 MPa at 16 mm with room-temperature toughness, and S355JR guarantees 355 MPa at 16 mm under the same impact condition.

The full ordering designation can also include the delivery condition and any special requirements, for example S355JR+AR for as-rolled plate. The JR class is the entry level of the four EN 10025-2 toughness classes; the others are J0 at 0 °C, J2 at -20 °C and K2 with 40 J at -20 °C.

Chemistry and Mechanical Properties Compared

Property S235JR (1.0038) S355JR (1.0045)
C max (%) 0.17 0.24
Mn max (%) 1.40 1.60
P max (%) 0.035 0.035
S max (%) 0.035 0.035
N max (%) 0.012 0.012
Cu max (%) 0.55 0.55
ReH min up to 16 mm (MPa) 235 355
Tensile strength (MPa) 360-510 470-630
Impact energy at +20 °C 27 J longitudinal 27 J longitudinal

Both grades de-rate with thickness. S235JR falls to 225 MPa over 16 mm up to 40 mm and to 215 MPa between 40 mm and 100 mm. S355JR falls to 345 MPa, then to 335 MPa and 325 MPa across the same bands. The roughly 120 MPa advantage therefore persists right through the plate range, which is why S355JR remains the workhorse for strength-governed heavy plate.

The chemistry difference is small but not irrelevant. The higher carbon and manganese of S355JR raise its carbon equivalent, so welding procedure qualification, heat input limits and preheat requirements are stricter than for S235JR even though both grades are fully weldable.

What the JR Toughness Class Means in Practice

JR only assures notch toughness at +20 °C. That is sufficient for indoor and temperate applications, but it does not qualify the steel for service below freezing, and it does not satisfy impact requirements written around 0 °C or -20 °C. Where low-temperature toughness is needed, either upgrade the suffix within the same strength level, for example S235J2 or S355J2, or specify the higher-strength grade with the appropriate suffix.

JR: 27 J at +20 °C - general indoor structures in mild climates.

J0: 27 J at 0 °C - cooler climates and moderate dynamic loading.

J2: 27 J at -20 °C - cold storage, outdoor and low-temperature service.

K2: 40 J at -20 °C - the toughest EN 10025-2 non-alloy class.

Equivalent Grades in ASTM, JIS and GB Standards

EN 10025-2 ASTM JIS China GB
S235JR A36 (min. 250 MPa), A283 Gr C SS400 Q235B (GB/T 700)
S355JR A572 Gr 50 SM490A, SS490 Q355B (GB/T 1591-2018)

Two cautions apply. First, ASTM A36 has a minimum yield of 250 MPa, which is above S235JR, but it carries no mandatory Charpy requirement and therefore cannot replace an impact-tested grade. Second, Q235B and Q355B are defined in different Chinese standards and with different limits, so composition and impact class must be compared line by line rather than assumed. Grades such as JIS SS400 are general structural steels used widely in Asia for beams and brackets, and conversion tables list them as approximate equivalents only.

Fabrication and Typical Applications

Both grades are supplied as hot-rolled plate with mill edge or trimmed edge, and both are suitable for shearing, gas and plasma cutting, drilling, machining and cold forming within normal radii. S235JR is common in general fabrication, frames, platforms, brackets and low-stress parts. S355JR is preferred for heavy beams and columns, crane girders, bridge components, storage tanks and machine bases where the extra yield strength reduces section size.

Whether the extra strength of S355JR is worth ordering depends on what governs the design. If deflection or buckling limits the member, the gain may be small; if bending stress or axial stress governs, the mass saving is usually decisive, and the delivered cost per kilogram of the two grades is close enough that the lighter structure wins.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is the main difference between S235JR and S355JR?
Minimum yield strength: 355 MPa for S355JR against 235 MPa for S235JR at a nominal thickness up to 16 mm.

Q: Is S235JR stronger than S355JR?
No. S235JR is the lower-strength grade; its lower yield strength is matched by slightly better ductility and welding tolerance.

Q: What is the Chinese equivalent of S355JR?
Q355B to GB/T 1591-2018 is the usual Chinese equivalent, while Q235B to GB/T 700 is the common equivalent of S235JR.

Q: What is the JIS equivalent of S355JR?
JIS SM490A and SS490 are commonly listed as the nearest Japanese grades in conversion tables.

Q: Can S235JR be used at low temperature?
No. JR is qualified at +20 °C only; specify J0 or J2 for service at 0 °C or -20 °C.

Q: Which grade is better for heavy plate?
S355JR retains about 315 MPa minimum yield at 100 mm against 215 MPa for S235JR, so it is preferred where stress governs.