S690Q vs A36: High Strength and General Structural Steel Plate Compared

Dec 03, 2025 Leave a message

S690QL-QUALITY-CERTIFICATE.pdf

Quick Answer: S690Q vs A36 at a Glance

S690Q and ASTM A36 are both structural steel plates, but they sit at opposite ends of the strength range. S690Q is a quenched and tempered plate to EN 10025-6 with a minimum yield strength of 690 MPa, while A36 is a hot rolled carbon steel to ASTM A36/A36M with a minimum yield strength of 250 MPa, which is 36 000 psi and gives the grade its name. S690Q is chosen when weight and load matter, A36 when cost, availability and easy fabrication matter.

Feature S690Q ASTM A36
Primary standard EN 10025-6 ASTM A36/A36M
Minimum yield strength 690 MPa up to 50 mm 250 MPa
Tensile strength 770 - 940 MPa 400 - 550 MPa
Delivery condition Quenched and tempered As rolled
Mandatory impact test 30 J at -20 °C Not required by the base grade
Typical role Weight critical, highly loaded structures General frames, supports, fabrications

What S690Q and A36 Actually Are

S690Q is produced under EN 10025-6, the European standard for flat products of high yield strength structural steels in the quenched and tempered condition. After rolling the plate is austenitised, quenched and then tempered, which produces a fine tempered martensitic or bainitic structure with high strength and good toughness. The grade is controlled for carbon equivalent so that it can still be welded with qualified procedures.

A36 is the most widely used general purpose structural carbon steel in North America. It is a low carbon, mild steel that is easy to weld, drill, punch and machine, available in plate, bar and structural shapes from a very large number of mills and distributors. Its chemical requirements are deliberately loose: carbon 0.26 % maximum, manganese 0.80 to 1.20 %, phosphorus 0.04 % maximum and sulphur 0.05 % maximum, with copper 0.20 % minimum when supplied as copper bearing steel.

Closest equivalents show how far apart the two grades are:

A36 in Europe: S235JR to EN 10025-2, the plain carbon structural grade.

A36 in Japan: SS400 to JIS G3101.

A36 in Canada: 260W to CSA G40.21; in India: E250 to IS 2062.

S690Q in China: Q690C to GB/T 16270 for the equivalent strength class.

Strength, Toughness and Heat Treatment Compared

Property S690Q ASTM A36
Yield strength ≥ 690 MPa for t ≤ 50 mm, 650 MPa for 50 - 100 mm, 630 MPa for 100 - 150 mm ≥ 250 MPa, no thickness step
Tensile strength 770 - 940 MPa for t ≤ 50 mm 400 - 550 MPa
Minimum elongation 14 % 20 % in 200 mm, 23 % in 50 mm
Charpy impact 30 J minimum at -20 °C, mandatory No impact requirement in the base specification
Heat treatment Quench and temper, controlled by the mill As rolled; no heat treatment step
Carbon equivalent control CEV reported and limited so welding remains feasible Not applicable to a plain carbon grade

Two consequences follow from this table. First, S690Q gives roughly 2.7 times the yield strength of A36, so a strength governed member can be far thinner. Second, A36 is far more ductile and forgiving: its elongation is higher and welding it needs no special discipline, which is exactly why it remains the default plate for ordinary structures.

Weight, Cost and Design Consequences

If a member is governed purely by strength, the required cross sectional area scales inversely with allowable stress, so a switch from A36 to S690Q would suggest a thickness reduction of roughly 60 %. Real designs rarely reach that figure, because stiffness, buckling, fatigue, bolt bearing and weld details set floors that strength alone cannot overcome. Practical savings of 25 % to 50 % in steel weight are typical on weight critical equipment such as crane booms, excavator arms and truck bodies.

On price per tonne, S690Q costs more than A36 because of the alloy content and the heat treatment. The comparison that matters is cost per unit of load carried, plus the secondary effects: lighter members reduce foundation size, transport cost, erection crane capacity and welding volume. Where a structure is governed by dead load or by transport limits, S690Q frequently wins on total cost even though the plate itself is dearer.

Choose by strength: S690Q saves weight and steel consumption.

Choose by simplicity: A36 saves engineering time and fabrication labour.

Check stiffness first: a thinner plate is not automatically lighter in service if deflection governs.

Check connections: higher strength steel concentrates force into welds and bolts, so detail design must keep pace.

Welding and Fabrication Differences

A36 is the reference point for easy welding: no preheat for normal thicknesses, standard electrodes and broad tolerance to heat input. S690Q requires a qualified approach:

Low hydrogen consumables matched to the parent plate strength, stored and handled correctly.

Preheat as a function of thickness, carbon equivalent and heat input, not as an optional extra.

Capped heat input and controlled interpass temperature to protect the heat affected zone.

Welding procedure qualification and welder approval for the actual grade and thickness combination.

Machined or ground cut edges before welding to remove any hardened thermal cut layer.

A36 also tolerates cold bending, flame straightening and field modification far better. S690Q should not be hot formed above its tempering range, because that destroys the quenched and tempered properties, and cold forming requires generous bend radii.

Which Plate Should You Specify?

The decision is usually straightforward once the governing load case is clear. S690Q pays for itself in mobile equipment, long span bridges, offshore structures, wind tower sections and heavy transport frames, where every kilogram removed from the structure adds payload or reduces cost downstream. A36 remains the right answer for building frames, platforms, walkways, supports, base plates, brackets and general fabrication, where a thicker plate is cheaper than a more demanding engineering process.

Both grades can be supplied in the same project: high strength plate in the heavily loaded chords and columns, A36 in secondary members, stiffeners and non critical details.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is S690Q stronger than A36?
Yes. S690Q has a minimum yield strength of 690 MPa against 250 MPa for A36, close to 2.7 times the load capacity for the same cross section.

Q: Can A36 be substituted for S690Q?
Usually not directly. Equivalent load capacity would require a much thicker section, which changes stiffness, connection geometry and weight.

Q: Which one is easier to weld?
A36 is easier. S690Q is weldable but needs low hydrogen consumables, preheat, limited heat input and a qualified welding procedure.

Q: What is the European equivalent of A36?
The closest equivalent is S235JR to EN 10025-2, a plain carbon structural steel of similar strength level.

Q: Does A36 require impact testing?
Not in the base grade. Charpy testing is only supplied when a purchaser specifies supplementary impact requirements.

Q: When is S690Q cheaper overall than A36?
When the structure is weight or load governed, so that thinner plate reduces steel volume, transport, foundations and erection cost.