S355J2 and S355NL sit close together on a mill certificate. Both are weldable structural steels with a minimum yield strength of 355 MPa and a tensile range of 470 to 630 MPa, so a fabricator can easily treat them as interchangeable. They are not. The two grades come from different product standards, and the temperature at which their notch toughness is guaranteed differs by 30 degrees, which decides whether a structure is safe in a cold climate or not.
Two Different Product Standards
| Item | S355J2 | S355NL |
|---|---|---|
| Product standard | EN 10025-2 | EN 10025-3 |
| Standard scope | Non-alloy structural steels | Weldable fine grain structural steels |
| Delivery condition | Hot rolled; normalized (+N) on request | Normalized or normalized rolled, mandatory |
| Charpy test temperature | Minus 20 °C | Minus 50 °C |
| Minimum absorbed energy | 27 J longitudinal | 27 J longitudinal |
| Typical cost and lead time | Lower, widely stocked | Higher, longer lead time |
EN 10025-2 covers general structural steels in the as-rolled, normalized or normalized rolled condition. EN 10025-3 is written specifically for fine grain steels that must be normalized, and its designation carries the letter N for normalized and, when applicable, the letter L for low-temperature properties. The second letter of the suffix therefore tells the reader the temperature class: J2 means testing at minus 20 °C, the NL combination means testing at minus 50 °C.
Impact Toughness: The Real Difference
The practical consequence of the standard split is the impact test. S355J2 is certified with a minimum of 27 J absorbed energy at minus 20 °C, while S355NL is certified with the same 27 J minimum at minus 50 °C in the longitudinal direction. Both figures are minimum values on Charpy V-notch specimens, so the difference is not the amount of energy but the temperature at which the steel is still able to deliver it.
S355NL achieves the lower transition temperature through a combination of fine grain practice, aluminum or niobium micro-alloying for grain refinement, and tighter limits on sulphur and phosphorus. Those measures push the ductile-to-brittle transition of the plate downwards, which is why the grade is chosen for the lowest design metal temperature rather than for its strength, since its room temperature strength is the same as that of S355J2.
Chemical Composition Compared
| Grade | Standard | C max % | Si max % | Mn % | P max % | S max % | N max % | Al min % |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S355NL | EN 10025-3 | 0.18 | 0.50 | 0.90 - 1.65 | 0.025 | 0.020 | 0.015 | 0.020 |
| S355J2 | EN 10025-2 | 0.20 | 0.55 | max 1.60 | 0.035 | 0.035 | 0.012 | - |
S355NL carries the tighter analysis: lower carbon, lower sulphur and phosphorus, and a mandatory minimum aluminum content that combines with nitrogen to protect grain size during normalizing. Residual elements such as copper, chromium, nickel and molybdenum are also restricted so that the fine grain structure is not disturbed by uncontrolled alloying; S355J2 tolerates a wider residual band because its properties are not dependent on a normalized fine grain structure.
Mechanical Properties
| Grade | Standard | Nominal thickness | ReH min | Rm | Impact test |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S355NL | EN 10025-3 | Up to 16 mm | 355 MPa | 470 - 630 MPa | 27 J at minus 50 °C |
| S355J2 | EN 10025-2 | Up to 16 mm | 355 MPa | 470 - 630 MPa | 27 J at minus 20 °C |
Yield strength declines gradually with thickness for both grades, and the two property tables track each other closely across the common plate range up to 100 mm. For this reason the selection decision is almost never made on strength; it is made on test temperature, weld criticality, toughness requirement in the heat affected zone and cost.
Welding, Cost and Application Selection
Weldability: S355J2 welded in thick sections normally requires preheating above roughly 30 mm and careful heat input control. S355NL welds more easily because its low sulphur and fine grain structure reduce the risk of cold cracking, so critical joints can often be completed with less preheat.
Cost and availability: S355J2 is produced in large tonnages as hot rolled stock, is cheaper and is available from stock. S355NL needs micro-alloying and a normalizing or normalized rolling route, so it costs more and carries a longer lead time.
Choose S355J2 for building frames, warehouses, general machine bases, storage tanks and structures in moderate climates where the service temperature stays above about minus 20 °C.
Choose S355NL for offshore platforms, bridges in cold regions, wind turbine towers, crane structures in freezing service and any component subject to high stress, low temperature or cyclic loading down to minus 50 °C.
A useful rule when reviewing a specification is to compare the lowest design metal temperature of the structure with the Charpy test temperature of each candidate grade. Where that design temperature falls below minus 20 °C, or where fatigue and brittle fracture consequences are severe, S355NL is the defensible choice; elsewhere S355J2 delivers the same strength at a lower cost.
FAQ
Q: What is the main difference between S355J2 and S355NL?
S355J2 is an EN 10025-2 steel impact tested at minus 20 °C, while S355NL is an EN 10025-3 fine grain steel supplied normalized and impact tested at minus 50 °C.
Q: Are S355J2 and S355NL the same strength?
Yes. Both have a minimum yield strength of 355 MPa up to 16 mm thickness and the same 470 - 630 MPa tensile strength range, so they differ in toughness and delivery condition, not in strength.
Q: Why is S355NL more expensive?
It requires controlled micro-alloying, tighter sulphur and phosphorus limits and a normalizing or normalized rolling route, which adds process cost and lead time compared with hot rolled S355J2.
Q: Which grade should be used at minus 40 °C?
S355NL, because its Charpy guarantee extends to minus 50 °C while S355J2 is only certified to minus 20 °C and may behave in a brittle manner below that temperature.
Q: Is preheating needed when welding S355J2?
Preheating is generally required for sections above about 30 mm to control cooling rate and hydrogen cracking; S355NL tolerates less preheat thanks to its low impurity and fine grain structure.
Q: Can S355J2 be supplied in a normalized condition?
Yes. S355J2 is normally hot rolled, but it can also be delivered in the normalized or normalized rolled condition when the purchase specification calls for it.




