51CrV4 and 50CrV4 are chromium-vanadium alloy spring steels used for high-strength, fatigue-loaded components such as coil and leaf springs, torsion bars, shafts and gears. Their analyses overlap almost completely, and the practical differences come from the carbon aim, the standard that governs the delivery, and the balance of hardness, toughness and fatigue life that follows from it.
What the Two Designations Represent
51CrV4 is the current European designation, material number 1.8159, listed for hot rolled spring steel in EN 10089 and for quenched and tempered steels in EN 10083-3. The name 50CrV4 comes from the earlier German spring steel standard DIN 17221 and describes essentially the same chromium-vanadium family; when the European standards were harmonised, the 51CrV4 designation became the one used on drawings and mill certificates, while 50CrV4 is still quoted in legacy drawings, spare-part lists and older catalogues.
In the United States the closest grade is AISI/SAE 6150, a chromium-vanadium spring steel with comparable chromium and vanadium levels. One practical consequence of this overlap is that a mill can usually roll both designations from a single heat by adjusting the carbon aim, so the choice between them is more a question of specification discipline than of metallurgical family.
Chemical Composition Comparison
| Element | 51CrV4 (1.8159) | 50CrV4 (former DIN designation) |
| Carbon (C) | 0.47 - 0.55, nominal 0.51 | 0.47 - 0.55, nominal 0.50 |
| Silicon (Si) | 0.15 - 0.40 | 0.15 - 0.40 |
| Manganese (Mn) | 0.70 - 1.10 | 0.70 - 1.10 |
| Phosphorus (P) | 0.025 max | 0.030 max |
| Sulfur (S) | 0.025 max | 0.030 max |
| Chromium (Cr) | 0.90 - 1.20 | 0.90 - 1.20 |
| Vanadium (V) | 0.10 - 0.20 | 0.10 - 0.20 |
The two grades therefore sit inside the same analysis window, and the difference in nominal carbon, 0.51% against 0.50%, is small. That single tenth of a percent still matters in hardening response, because carbon controls how much martensite hardness can be developed and how much tempered hardness is retained after the spring is stress relieved.
Mechanical Properties and Hardenability
| Property (typical, quenched and tempered) | 51CrV4 | 50CrV4 |
| Tensile strength (MPa) | 1150 - 1450 | 1100 - 1400 |
| 0.2% proof strength (MPa) | 950 min | 900 min |
| Elongation in 50 mm (%) | 6 - 10 | 7 - 11 |
| Hardness after tempering | 32 - 46 HRC as ordered | 30 - 44 HRC as ordered |
| Charpy V-notch impact at 20 °C (J) | 20 min | 25 min |
Values depend on section size, quench severity and tempering temperature, so plates and bars are normally ordered to a hardness window after tempering rather than to a single strength figure. Both grades harden well because chromium raises hardenability and vanadium refines the grain and retards softening during tempering. At equal tempering temperature the slightly higher carbon of 51CrV4 gives marginally higher tempered hardness and strength, while 50CrV4 keeps a little more ductility and impact energy.
Heat Treatment and Fatigue Performance
Typical treatment for both grades is austenitising in the 850-880 °C range, oil quenching, then tempering between roughly 400 °C and 550 °C according to the required strength and toughness combination. The vanadium addition is what makes the grade attractive for springs: it pins grain growth during austenitising and forms fine carbides that resist over-tempering, so the component holds its hardness in service.
Fatigue is the design driver for spring steel. Surface decarburisation, inclusions, seams and grinding marks all act as crack initiators, so spring plate and bar are specified with decarburisation limits and clean-steel requirements in addition to the chemistry table. Shot peening and a defined residual compressive stress at the surface raise the endurance limit substantially; in rotating bending the fatigue strength of these grades is typically close to half of the tensile strength when the surface is sound.
Applications and Grade Selection
50CrV4 is widely used for coil and leaf springs, torsion bars, clutch and suspension components, and driveline parts where a balance of strength, ductility and fatigue resistance is required.
51CrV4 suits the same product families where a slightly higher hardness, wear resistance or load capacity is needed, for example heavy-duty springs, spring plates and highly stressed machine parts.
Fabrication covers quenched and tempered plate, hot rolled bar, and strip for forming before hardening and tempering; decarburisation-free surfaces are specified for spring products.
Welding is not recommended for these medium-carbon steel grades; if a weld is unavoidable, preheating, matching low-hydrogen consumables and immediate post-weld heat treatment are required.
Substitution between the two designations is usually possible on a technical basis, but the drawing, the hardness specification and the customer approval must all agree before a swap is made.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the difference between 50CrV4 and 51CrV4?
The main difference is the carbon aim, about 0.50% against 0.51%, inside the same 0.47-0.55% window. 51CrV4 is the current EN designation and reaches marginally higher tempered hardness, while 50CrV4 retains slightly better ductility.
Q: Is 51CrV4 the same as 1.8159?
Yes. 1.8159 is the material number of 51CrV4 in the European numbering system, the grade commonly referenced in EN 10089 for hot rolled spring steel and in EN 10083-3 for quenched and tempered steel.
Q: What is the US equivalent of 51CrV4?
AISI/SAE 6150 is the closest chromium-vanadium spring steel grade, with similar chromium and vanadium levels and comparable hardenability behaviour.
Q: What is the Japanese equivalent of 50CrV4?
JIS SUP10 is the closest spring steel grade and is frequently quoted as an equivalent in cross-reference tables for chromium-vanadium spring steels.
Q: Is 51CrV4 good for springs?
Yes. It is a medium-carbon chromium-vanadium spring steel with high strength, good toughness and excellent fatigue resistance after quenching and tempering, which is exactly what repeated-load spring applications require.
Q: What hardness can these grades reach after hardening?
As-quenched martensite can exceed 55 HRC in thin sections, but finished springs are tempered to a working window, commonly between 30 HRC and 46 HRC, to balance fatigue strength against toughness.




