A515 Gr 60, 65, 70 vs A516 Gr 70 vs A537 Class 1, 2, 3 Plate

May 07, 2025 Leave a message

ASTM-A515.pdf

Pressure Vessel Plate Grades Kept in Stock

Boiler and pressure vessel fabricators usually work from a small group of plate grades that between them cover the strength and temperature range of most shop orders: the carbon-silicon A515 series in Grade 60, Grade 65 and Grade 70, the silicon-killed A516 Grade 70, and the heat-treated carbon-manganese A537 in Class 1, Class 2 and Class 3. All of them are weldable plate grades intended for the shells, drums, heads and tanks of stationary equipment, but they are not interchangeable, because each one is qualified for a different combination of strength, service temperature and toughness.

Holding these grades in stock shortens lead times, particularly when a fabricator needs several thicknesses from the same family for one vessel, or when a repair calls for a small quantity at short notice.

A515 Gr 60, Gr 65 and Gr 70 Carbon-Silicon Plate

The A515 family is made to ASTM A515 / ASME SA515 for intermediate- and higher-temperature service in welded boilers and pressure vessels. Silicon is added as a deoxidizer and strengthens the ferrite, which suits the grade to hot service rather than to low-temperature duty. Grade 60, Grade 65 and Grade 70 are the three strength levels in the specification; the number refers to the minimum tensile strength in ksi, so Grade 70 is the highest and the most widely ordered of the three, while Grades 60 and 65 are selected for lighter or less highly stressed components.

Grade 70 is the common choice for boiler drums, shells and heads, with a minimum yield strength of 260 MPa and a tensile range of 485 - 620 MPa.

Grades 60 and 65 sit below Grade 70 in strength and are used where the design stress allows a lighter, more economical plate.

Plates are typically supplied normalized, and are also available as-rolled, normalized and tempered, or quenched and tempered.

A515 is a higher-temperature grade: it is not intended for low-temperature impact service, and it is not recommended for sour service where resistance to hydrogen-induced cracking is required.

A516 Gr 70 Silicon-Killed Plate

A516 Grade 70 is the silicon-killed plate of the same strength level as A515 Grade 70, with a minimum yield strength of 260 MPa and a tensile strength of 485 - 620 MPa. The essential difference is duty temperature. A516 plate is produced with fine grain practice and can be ordered with impact testing at low temperature, so it is the usual choice for vessels that must demonstrate toughness below the range covered by A515. Because the two grades are close in chemistry as well as in strength, they are often ordered together for the same project, with A515 used for the hotter sections and A516 for components exposed to lower temperature or to impact loading.

A537 Class 1, 2 and 3 Heat-Treated Plate

ASTM A537 covers carbon-manganese-silicon plate for pressure vessels, supplied in the normalized condition in Class 1 and in the quenched and tempered condition in Class 2 and Class 3. The higher classes offer increased strength together with improved toughness, which is why they are selected for thicker and more highly stressed vessels. A537 plate is dimensionally stable after heat treatment and takes welding well, provided that the qualified procedure accounts for the strength level ordered and, where the construction code requires it, for post-weld heat treatment.

How to Choose Between the Grades

Grade Strength level Supply condition Typical duty
A515 Gr 60 Lowest of the A515 series Normalized or as-rolled Warmer service, lightly stressed shells
A515 Gr 65 Intermediate Normalized or as-rolled Boiler and vessel plate at moderate stress
A515 Gr 70 260 MPa min yield, 485 - 620 MPa tensile Normalized, N plus T or Q plus T Boiler drums, high-pressure heaters, hot process vessels
A516 Gr 70 Same strength level as A515 Gr 70 Normalized or as-rolled, optional impact testing Vessels requiring low-temperature toughness
A537 Cl 1 Higher strength than A515 Gr 70 Normalized Thicker pressure vessels
A537 Cl 2 and Cl 3 Higher strength with improved toughness Quenched and tempered Heavy-wall, high-integrity vessels

Selection normally follows three questions: what is the design metal temperature, what toughness must be demonstrated at that temperature, and what strength does the design stress require. The first two questions decide between the A515 and A516 families; the third decides the grade within the family and whether A537 is needed at all.

Stock Sizes and Handling Notes

A515 and A516 plate are commonly held in thicknesses from about 6 mm up to 300 mm, in widths of roughly 1500 mm to 4050 mm and in lengths of 3000 mm to 15000 mm, with 6 m and 12 m the most common mill lengths. A537 is generally stocked in the medium to heavy thickness range where its higher strength reduces the wall thickness required.

Plate can be cut to size, drilled, tapped, bevelled and profile cut at the warehouse before dispatch.

Certificates to EN 10204 3.1 are standard, with 3.2 certification and third-party inspection available when requested.

Stock plate should be stored clear of the ground with edges protected, because surface damage or corrosion pitting can affect a vessel under construction.

When more than one grade is used on a vessel, mark the identity of every plate so that the correct material reaches each component.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is the difference between ASTM A515 and ASTM A516 plate?
Both are carbon steel pressure vessel plates. A515 is a carbon-silicon grade normalized for higher-temperature service, while A516 is silicon-killed and made to fine grain practice, so it can be ordered with low-temperature impact testing.

Q: Which of these grades is stocked most often?
A515 Gr 70 and A516 Gr 70 in the intermediate thicknesses, together with A537 in the heavier thicknesses where extra strength is needed.

Q: What is A537 Class 1 used for?
It is normalized carbon-manganese-silicon plate for thicker pressure vessels that need more strength than A515 Gr 70 provides.

Q: Are A515 Grade 60, 65 and 70 different steels?
They are three strength levels of the same specification. The number is the minimum tensile strength in ksi, so Grade 70 is the strongest and Grade 60 the least strong.

Q: Can these plates be cut to size before delivery?
Yes. Cut-to-size rectangles, circle-cut head blanks, drilling, tapping and bevelled or profile-cut edges are all part of normal warehouse processing.

Q: What certification comes with stock plate?
A mill test certificate to EN 10204 3.1 is standard, and 3.2 certification or inspection by an independent third party can be arranged on request.